top of page

Hitting Is an Incident. Control Is a Climate.

Writer: Steven Marshall
Steven Marshall
Oct 9
11 min read

Welcome back to your favorite cybercorner—StevenSays.


So this is Domestic Violence Awareness Month so let's talk.


Not all abuse leaves a bruise. Some of it leaves you questioning your memory, shrinking your personality, apologizing for things you didn’t do, and carefully choosing your words because you’re afraid of what might happen if you say the wrong thing.


When we talk about abuse, many people immediately picture physical violence. They imagine hitting, slapping, pushing, or other forms of physical aggression. And while physical abuse is serious and must never be minimized, there is another form of harm that often goes unnoticed because it does not always leave visible evidence.


It is the kind of harm that happens through intimidation, manipulation, humiliation, isolation, threats, and control.


It is the kind of harm that can change how a person thinks, feels, behaves, and sees themselves.

And sometimes, the most damaging part is that the person experiencing it may not even recognize it as abuse.


Hitting Is an Incident. Control Is a Climate.


There is a difference between an incident and an environment. An incident is something that happens at a particular moment. A climate is the atmosphere in which someone lives, breathes, thinks, and makes decisions.


Physical violence can be a devastating incident. But coercive control—the repeated pattern of behaviors used to dominate another person's choices, freedom, and independence—can become a climate that surrounds nearly every aspect of daily life.


It can determine what someone wears, who they talk to, where they go, how they spend money, and whether they feel safe expressing an opinion.


In a controlling environment, a person may never know when the next argument will begin. They may become hyperaware of facial expressions, changes in tone, footsteps, silence, or the way a door closes.


They learn to anticipate reactions rather than freely express themselves.


They begin asking questions such as:


- Will saying this make them angry?

- Should I keep my opinion to myself?

- Will I be accused of being disrespectful if I disagree?

- Do I need to explain where I have been, who I spoke to, or why I made a particular decision?

- Is it easier to give in than to deal with another argument?


Over time, life becomes less about personal choice and more about managing someone else's reactions.


That is what makes control a climate: it does not have to happen every minute to influence every decision.


Why Is Non-Physical Abuse So Often Overlooked?


One reason non-physical abuse is overlooked is that our understanding of abuse is often tied to what we can see. A bruise is visible. A broken object is visible. A physical injury may be documented, photographed, or treated.


But what does emotional intimidation look like? What does psychological manipulation look like? How do you photograph the anxiety someone experiences before walking through their own front door?


How do you measure the exhaustion of constantly defending your intentions, explaining your decisions, or trying to prove that your memories are accurate?


These experiences are much harder to document, and that can make them easier for others to dismiss.


1. There May Be No Visible Evidence


A person can appear healthy, successful, confident, and emotionally stable in public while experiencing significant distress in private. They may go to work, raise children, attend church, maintain friendships, and fulfill responsibilities. Because their lives appear functional, people may assume everything is fine.


But functioning is not the same as feeling safe.


Someone can be successful in nearly every area of life and still feel trapped in a relationship where their autonomy is repeatedly challenged.


2. The Behavior May Be Disguised as Love


Control does not always introduce itself as control.


Sometimes, it sounds like:


- “I'm only doing this because I love you.”

- “I'm trying to protect you.”

- “If you had nothing to hide, you wouldn't mind me checking your phone.”

- “I wouldn't get so upset if you would just listen.”

- “Nobody else is going to love you like I do.”

- “You're making me act this way.”


Statements like these can blur the line between care and control. Healthy love may involve concern, boundaries, accountability, and disagreement. But healthy love does not require one person to surrender their independence to keep the other person emotionally stable.


Protection respects your freedom. Control attempts to replace it.


3. The Behavior May Be Normalized Over Time


Not every controlling relationship begins with obvious intimidation. Sometimes, the pattern develops gradually. One question becomes an interrogation. One disagreement becomes a punishment. One request becomes an expectation that cannot be challenged.


The person experiencing the behavior may adjust little by little.


They stop sharing certain information. They avoid particular friends. They change how they dress. They become more careful about what they say. Eventually, they may not recognize how much of their lives they have reorganized around avoiding another person's reaction. What once felt unacceptable may begin to feel normal simply because it happens so often.


4. People May Blame the Victim Instead of Examining the Pattern


When someone discloses emotional or psychological abuse, they may hear:


“Why don't you just leave?”

“Maybe you're too sensitive.”

“Every relationship has problems.”

“You know how that person is.”


These responses can unintentionally reinforce shame and silence. Leaving or confronting an abusive person may involve emotional, financial, practical, family-related, or safety concerns. A person may also still love the individual who is hurting them.


We must stop assuming that someone who remains in a difficult relationship must be comfortable with what is happening.


Sometimes, people remain because they are afraid. Sometimes, they are hopeful things will change. Sometimes, they are trying to protect their children, maintain housing, or figure out how to move forward safely.


Instead of asking why they have not left, we can begin by asking what support, information, and resources they need.


The Damage of Living Under Constant Control


Non-physical abuse is not harmless simply because it does not involve hitting.

Repeated intimidation, humiliation, manipulation, and coercive control can affect a person's emotional well-being, relationships, physical health, and sense of identity.


Let's look at some of the ways this can happen.


1. It Can Erode Your Sense of Self


Healthy relationships allow room for individuality. You can have your own thoughts, preferences, friendships, and opinions without fearing that every difference will become a battle.

In a controlling relationship, individuality may gradually feel dangerous.

You may begin second-guessing decisions you once made confidently. You may seek permission for things you previously handled independently. You may silence your opinions to preserve temporary peace.


Over time, you can lose touch with the person you were before the relationship became dominated by fear and conflict.


You might find yourself wondering, “Why am I not as confident as I used to be?”

Sometimes, the answer is not that you have become weaker. It may be that you have been living in an environment that repeatedly discourages your independence.


2. It Can Create Chronic Anxiety and Hypervigilance


When someone repeatedly experiences unpredictable anger, threats, or emotional punishment, their nervous system may begin anticipating danger even when no immediate conflict is occurring. They may experience racing thoughts, muscle tension, difficulty sleeping, irritability, stomach discomfort, or an inability to relax. They may listen for changes in someone's voice, monitor their facial expressions, or mentally rehearse conversations before having them.


This is exhausting.


Imagine being unable to enjoy a peaceful evening because part of your mind is preparing for the next disagreement.


Imagine feeling your heart race when your phone rings because you do not know whether the conversation will be ordinary or confrontational.


When conflict becomes unpredictable, the body may begin responding to the possibility of conflict before anything has actually happened.


These reactions do not mean a person is weak or irrational. They can be responses to prolonged stress. They deserve understanding and, when needed, professional support.


3. It Can Undermine Your Trust in Your Own Reality


One particularly damaging pattern is gaslighting, a form of psychological manipulation in which someone repeatedly attempts to make another person doubt their memory, perceptions, or understanding of events.


It may sound like:


- “That never happened.”

- “You're imagining things.”

- “You're too emotional to understand.”

- “You're always making me the bad guy.”

- “You need help because you think everything is about you.”


Not every disagreement about what happened is gaslighting. People can remember events differently, misunderstand one another, or disagree without deliberately manipulating each other.

The concern is a repeated pattern of denying, distorting, or weaponizing reality in ways that undermine another person's confidence in their own judgment.


When this happens repeatedly, a person may begin seeking constant reassurance, questioning clear memories, or relying on the other person to determine what is true.


They may become so focused on proving what happened that they lose sight of the larger issue:

How they are being treated.


You do not have to win every argument about the past to recognize that a pattern of intimidation or disrespect is hurting you.


4. It Can Damage Your Relationships With Other People


Control can also work by creating distance between a person and their support system. A controlling partner may criticize friends, discourage family visits, demand constant access to someone's time, or create conflict whenever that person spends time away from them.


Sometimes, isolation is direct. Other times, it happens indirectly.


A person may stop accepting invitations because explaining where they have been is exhausting. They may withdraw from family because they do not want to answer questions. They may stop confiding in friends because they are embarrassed or afraid of being judged.


Eventually, their world becomes smaller.


And when a person becomes disconnected from supportive relationships, it may become harder to recognize unhealthy patterns or find help.


Healthy love should not require you to abandon every meaningful relationship outside of it.


5. It Can Make Peace Feel More Important Than Freedom


One of the most troubling effects of a controlling environment is that a person may begin confusing the absence of conflict with the presence of safety.


They may think, “Things are good as long as I don't bring up certain subjects.”

Or, “If I agree, explain myself enough, and avoid upsetting them, we can have a good day.”


But peace that depends on one person constantly suppressing their needs is not mutual peace. It is compliance.


There is a difference between choosing compromise because you care about a relationship and surrendering your voice because you fear the consequences of disagreement.


One is a relationship skill. The other may be a survival strategy.


What Does Healthy Conflict Look Like?


Let's be clear: not every argument, difficult personality, selfish decision, or relationship disagreement constitutes abuse.


People become frustrated. They misunderstand one another. They sometimes speak poorly, need space, or struggle to regulate their emotions.


The difference often lies in the broader pattern, the use of power, the impact on autonomy, and the willingness to take responsibility.


In a healthy relationship:


- Disagreement does not eliminate your right to speak.

- Boundaries can be discussed without threats or intimidation.

- Both people can acknowledge mistakes.

- Apologies are accompanied by efforts to change.

- Privacy and reasonable independence are respected.

- Neither person must live in constant fear of the other's reactions.


In a controlling relationship, disagreement may lead to punishment, intimidation, surveillance, humiliation, or retaliation.


One person may consistently dictate the terms of the relationship, while the other is expected to adapt.


Healthy conflict allows both people to remain individuals. Coercive control attempts to make one person's freedom conditional on the other's approval.


How Can You Begin Recognizing the Pattern?


If you are concerned about your relationship, consider these questions. They are not a diagnostic test, but they may help you reflect on your experience.


Ask yourself:


1. Do I feel free to disagree without fearing retaliation?

2. Have I changed my behavior primarily to prevent another person's anger?

3. Do I feel that I must constantly prove my innocence, intentions, or honesty?

4. Am I becoming more isolated from people who care about me?

5. Do I feel responsible for managing another adult's emotions?

6. When I express a boundary, is it respected, or does it trigger intimidation and punishment?

7. Do I feel more confident and secure in this relationship, or increasingly anxious and unsure of myself?


Look beyond isolated moments and consider the pattern over time.

You do not have to label your relationship immediately to take your discomfort seriously. You can begin by acknowledging what you experience, identifying what is happening, and considering what support you need.


Practical Steps Toward Emotional Safety

Recognizing a controlling pattern can be difficult, especially when the behavior has become familiar. Moving toward greater safety and clarity does not have to happen all at once.


1. Pay attention to patterns, not just promises.

Notice whether harmful behavior repeats after apologies. Genuine accountability involves recognizing the harm, respecting boundaries, and making sustained changes—not simply expecting the other person to move on.


2. Reconnect with trusted support.

Consider speaking privately with a trusted friend, family member, counselor, or domestic violence advocate. Choose someone who will take your concerns seriously and respect your safety.


3. Rebuild trust in your own judgment.

If it is safe to do so, privately write down what happened, how you felt, and what you need. This can help you recognize patterns over time. Keep any notes somewhere the other person cannot access if monitoring or retaliation is a concern.


4. Remember that boundaries are about what you will do.

A boundary might sound like, “I am willing to discuss this respectfully, but I will step away from a conversation that involves threats or intimidation.”

However, setting a boundary is not always safe in a controlling relationship. If you believe expressing a boundary could increase danger, prioritize safety planning and seek confidential guidance rather than feeling pressured to confront the person.


5. Seek professional help when needed.

A licensed mental health professional can help you process anxiety, rebuild self-trust, understand trauma-related responses, and explore options without judgment. If coercive control or abuse is present, seek a professional who understands relationship abuse and can help you consider safety. Joint counseling may not be appropriate when one partner is using coercion or intimidation.


If you are in immediate danger, contact emergency services if you can do so safely. In the United States, the National Domestic Violence Hotline is available at 800-799-7233, by texting START to 88788, or through [thehotline.org](https://www.thehotline.org). Use a safer device if you are concerned that your communications are being monitored.


A Final Thought: You Deserve More Than the Absence of Violence


Sometimes, we measure the health of a relationship by asking whether anyone has been hit. But that question is not enough. We must also ask whether people feel safe speaking, thinking, disagreeing, making decisions, maintaining relationships, and being themselves. We must ask whether love is being expressed through mutual respect or used as a justification for control.

And we must remember that a person does not have to experience physical violence before their emotional well-being matters.


Hitting is an incident. Control is a climate. And living in that climate can slowly change how a person experiences the world, relationships, and themselves.


A relationship should not require you to shrink to keep someone else comfortable. You should not have to abandon your voice to avoid an argument, surrender your independence to prove your love, or question your worth to preserve a relationship.


Love can challenge us. It can require compromise, patience, accountability, and growth. But love should not systematically deprive us of our autonomy, dignity, or sense of safety.

If this message resonates with you, I encourage you to reflect on the difference between a relationship that occasionally experiences conflict and an environment in which you are continually expected to manage, appease, or fear another person.


And if someone you care about is experiencing this, remember: you do not have to force them to see what you see. Sometimes, the most helpful thing you can do is listen without judgment, remain a source of support, and remind them that they deserve to be treated with dignity.

Let's continue creating conversations that bring hidden struggles into the light, because what we cannot always see can still cause profound harm—and what we are willing to talk about, we are better equipped to recognize.


Thanks for stopping by StevenSays—your favorite cyber-corner for conversations about mental health, relationships, healing, and emotional wellness.


See you next time!




 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page